Research & Studies

The Case of the Ferryman, the Track-Watchman, and the Gardener with Artificial Intelligence, or the Maze of Epistemic Authority Transfer

Our institute’s researcher, László Z. Karvalics has written a commentary and it was released in Magyar Tudomány in 2026. The article’s full title is The Case of the Ferryman, the Track-Watchman, and the Gardener with Artificial Intelligence, or the Maze of Epistemic Authority Transfer – Comments on Dániel Golden’s Study.

Abstract

In his article entitled “Mesterséges intelligencia és társas tudás” (Artificial Intelligence and Social Knowledge), Dániel Golden argues that our cognitive ambitions inevitably lead us towards symbiotic human–machine systems. Rather than clarifying or debating his inspiring ideas, my primary goal in reflecting on them is to highlight the meaning and excitement inherent in the ongoing dialogue surrounding the subject. I believe that the term “symbiotic” does not accurately capture the essential aspects of the human–machine relationship, and that “hybrid system” is a more precise and expressive term. The dilemmas of extending the mind to external devices become less problematic when we realize that, as we increasingly rely on AI solutions, many important cognitive functions and roles that have traditionally been associated with humans are only metonymically transferred to machines. Behind the social turn of AI, the next turn is looming, which I would call “ecosystemic” for lack of a better term.

Keywords: artificial intelligence (AI), epistemology, symbiosis, hybrid systems, AI Literacy

The article is available HERE with full text in Hungarian.